Monday, December 15, 2008
chapters 8&9
"Two groups a day in a classs with three reading groups guarantees guided reading time for each child finve times during a two week period" Is this enough time for each child to receive individual instruction? This doesn't sound like enough time to me. If it is, then isn't it important to continue our direct instruction with a basal, along with guided reading? I do agree that teachers need to expect changes and always be willing to change kids to different groups because it's a continusly developing process. This methodology is different from ability grouping that was done in the 1980's. In the 1990's our teaching philosophy was whole language, which has some guided reading aspects to it. I do feel that when we take a look at guided reading, we need to make sure that we don't use this program as a substitution for an entire reading program. Don't we need a sequential skill oriented "core" program along with guided reading? Otherwise, we may make the same mistakes in our teaching that we did with whole language. It's just a thought, and I'd like to hear yours!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
I think that using guided reading can be a core curriculum because not all students need the same skills. Some need the -ing ending, some need abc sounds, and some need only comprehension skills. Teaching instruction in guided reading is based on what each individual student needs and demonstrates in their reading- that is how you group- by what skills they need to learn and what reading books fit with that. Guided reading is not a supplement- I think just the opposite- the Harcourt is the supplement with the skills to be taught as a guide - not all my students do the pages with the letter v- they already know it. Instead of them doing the work with that, they write about what they are reading in their guided reading boxes. If everyone is struggling with a certain skill then I do a whole group lesson on it. We do read the stories in Harcourt together or in small groups- but again many of my students can already read them well the first time so they don't spend as much time with it or they read with those who struggle so good readers can be heard. Does that explain it a little better?
Kathy,
Some of the questions I have are: will you still follow the critical skills already determined? Do you then pretest or preassess students on their skills? How do you determine the skills needed to be taught - student needs or teacher determined? Both?
I agree with Anna in the concern: will there be a sequential skill program or guidelines? Just wondering.
Post a Comment