Tuesday, March 31, 2009
Chapter 15
Irene Fountas writes about compensatory programs for low achievers on page 191. She says that evaluation of compensatory programs reveals poor results. "Students who are behind their peers almost never catch up. Moreover, much time is wasted removing studetns from classrooms and providing programs that are ineffective and inconsistent with classroom instruction. Students who go down the hall to reading spend a gread deal of time doing just that: some researchers have even suggested that they would profit more from spending the time in their classroom instructional programs." What does this mean for my Title pull-out program that is a "Targeted" Title program that is mandated to only serve students who qualify for Title? What does a compensatory program mean? What about this quote from the National Reading Panel (2000) "Growth in word-reading skills is strongly enhanced by systematic phonics instruction.....Growth in reading comprehension is also boosted by systematic phonics instruction for younger students and reading-disabled students. These finding should dispel any belief that teaching phonics systematically yo young children interferes with their ability to read and comprehend text." Programs such as: Lindamood Therapy, Fluency Foundation, Read Well, Language, are all reading programs that are COMPREHENSIVE and SYSTEMATIC and are geared for children who are qualified for Special Ed. or Title. Yes, I do feel that one-on-one instruction is the way to go, but their is research given that a teacher can work with a group of up to four students and make just as much gains. Also, a teacher can work one-on -one with a child but be using the wrong reading instruction for that child. Just because a child is receiving one-on-one instruction doesn't mean that this child will benefit. It needs to be quality instruction that meets the child's needs and I do believe that one program does not fit for every child. "One shoe size does not fit all." This is my philosophy and I'm sticken to it!!!!!!!!!!!!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment